For many, opening a café is a lifelong dream! And why wouldn’t it be? Coffee shops are a fun and great way to give back to the community. However, like many other business endeavors, café businesses offer a unique set of challenges.

It is essential to understand the shortcomings of owning a café business, so you can know what to expect and how to rise above them. 

The most common disadvantages associated with coffee businesses include:

  • Highly Competitive Industry 

  • Requires Extensive and Constant Marketing
  • High Risk of Failing
  • Relies Heavily on Customer Service
  • Time-Consuming Endeavor
  • Countless Responsibilities 
  • Legalities & Bureaucracy 
  • Staffing 

Below we will go over each of them so you can make an educated decision and know what to expect when opening a coffee shop:

Highly Competitive Industry 

Let’s begin with the most obvious. As you might have already gathered, it seems like every street has one (if not two) coffee shops. Based on a recent census, there are currently 37,189 coffeehouse stores nationwide. So, it is no secret that the café business is a highly competitive industry.

Therefore, if you want your shop to succeed, you will need to develop a plan to set yourself apart from the competition and break through the clutter. Café Business Disadvantages

Requires Extensive and Constant Marketing

A highly saturated market, or like marketers call it a “red ocean,” will demand constant and extensive marketing on your part to reach your desired target audience and build long-lasting relationships.

An effective marketing plan is essential for your café business’ success. You will need to create a thorough marketing plan that includes short-term and long-term tactics and be ready to invest a considerable chunk of your initial investment.

Plus, marketing is not a one-time expense. You will need to include the costs associated with advertising your business in your monthly budget. More so, according to the Small Business Association (SBA), small businesses should allocate 7-8 percent of their revenues to marketing.

Check out our marketing tips HERE.

High Risk of Failing

Arguably one, if not the, most significant disadvantages of opening a café business is how often it doesn’t work out. For instance, a recent survey conducted by Coffee Shop Owners on 232 coffee shops in the country observed that between 50%- 74% of independent coffee shops fail in the first five years.

And we all know that failing means losing a considerable amount of money. If you stop to think that, on average, you need to invest between $100,000 – $400,000 for a worthy location and all the necessary equipment to open a coffee shop, knowing that there is more than a 50% chance that you could fail can render it a non-viable business option.

Relies Heavily on Customer Service

Coffee shops and café businesses, in general, rely heavily on customer service. And while it could be considered an advantage if you have a great team working for (and with) you, it is also a double-edged sword. Café Business Disadvantages

If customers are unhappy with your service, odds are they will not come back to your shop as they probably have plenty of other nearby options that can satisfy their need for coffee.

Thus, if you want to ensure your customers are getting the best possible customer service, you will need to keep your employees happy. To do so, you need to make sure you offer a great working environment, a decent paycheck, and other benefits that could render your shop a high commodity.

Time-Consuming Endeavor

All entrepreneurs indeed dedicate countless hours to their business endeavors. However, cafés are specially tome consuming as they usually open pretty early in the morning and tend to close late. Of course, your business’s schedule will be highly influenced by your target audience and location.

Plus, as a business owner, you will also be responsible for many other “behind the scenes” tasks that keep the business running, such as dealing with suppliers, keeping up the inventory, doing taxes, and more. Thus, you need to be prepared and willing to invest most of your time in your shop.

Countless Responsibilities 

That last element brings us to another “con” of owning a café business, or any other type of business for that matter, which is: having countless responsibilities.

When running a coffee shop, you are responsible for virtually everything that happens — from staffing, inventory, and payroll to maintenance, business planning, accounting, and marketing.

So, you need to be able to draft a detailed and calculated business plan to follow. Additionally, you need to be able to delegate some of the less critical tasks. To do so, you need to make sure you hire efficient, proactive, and supportive staff members for your team. 

Legalities & Bureaucracy 

Café Business DisadvantagesThe licenses or permits needed to open a coffee shop will vary greatly depending on location. But, you must know that you will need a few permits and licenses before being able to open.

As a rule of thumb, you will need the following legalities to legally operate your café business within the United States:

  • Business License
  • Food Service License
  • Health Permit
  • Food Handler’s Permit
  • Sign Permit
  • Employee Identification Number/ Tax ID

Additionally, you might also be required to have the necessary insurance policies in case anything goes south. The most common insurance policies for coffee shops and cafés include:

  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial General Liability
  • Business Income Insurance
  • Workers Compensation

Nonetheless, coffee shop owners could also benefit from having Equipment Insurance, Utility Insurance, and Spoilage Insurance. And in case you will also offer a delivery service or are planning to do any work for your business behind the wheel, it is advisable to secure Commercial Auto Insurance.

As you might have already gathered, owning a café demands a lot and comes with a long list of challenges to overcome. Nonetheless, do not get discouraged! There are many ways to overcome these challenges through thoughtful business planning, commitment, and consistent execution.

Plus, there are also many very appealing benefits and advantages to owning a café business.

Benefits of Owning a Café Business 

As we mentioned above, owning a café business also comes with a list of benefits and advantages worth mentioning. Some of the most relevant include:

• Large Demand

Firmly planted on the spectrum’s pro side is that coffee is a popular and common beverage, meaning people drink it daily without even thinking about it. According to a study conducted by the National Coffee Association (NCA), 64% of adults in the United States currently consume coffee every day —drinking about 400 million cups of coffee every day.

Hence, it is safe to say that there is a great demand for coffee in the country, rendering coffee businesses highly lucrative.

• Stable Market

Another great advantage is that café shops operate in a very stable industry. The U.S. coffee market brings in a reported $5.18 billion in sales annually. Moreover, by 2025, the global coffee shop market is predicted to be worth at least $237.6 billion.

A stable market supported by an extensive product demand makes the perfect business venture.

• High-Profit Margins

Certainly, another pro to consider when deciding whether you should open a café business is profit margins. A coffee shop can be an extremely high-profit margin business when compared to others in the foodservice industry.

The median profit margin for regular coffee drinks is 15-20%, while the medium profit margin for specialty coffee drinks is roughly 12-18%. In other words, many coffee shops make 70% gross profit per cup of coffee.

• Growth Potential

Big players like Starbucks and Caribou Coffee are living proof that there is enormous growth potential within the café business. And once more, statistics are on your side! According to a 2021 study analyzing the global coffee market’s growth trends, the coffee industry is growing at a significantly large compound growth rate of around 5.5% through the forecasting period (2019-2024).

More so, numbers indicate that the most drastic growth is expected to occur in China and the United States.

Related Questions

1. Is owning a coffee shop profitable?

Yes! Coffee shops can be very profitable businesses when managed efficiently. According to the SBA, on average, a small to a medium-sized coffee shop in the United States can make between $60,000 to $160,000 in personal income for the shop owner. 

More so, for many shops, sales often double within three to five years. Thus, as a café owner, you could even amount to make up to $300,000 a year depending on effectively you run your business.

2. How important is the location for a café business?

Location is critical for most consumer-oriented businesses  — even more so when operating in a highly competitive market like the coffee industry. Thus, when choosing the perfect place for your café, make sure you have thoroughly vetted the location and consider street visibility, accessibility, overall space, and competition.

Additionally, before you set your heart on a specific location, consider the area’s demographics. Choosing a location based on your audience is a smart business move to consider. Thus, ask yourself if your location is home to your target audience or if you will be better off somewhere else.  

Café Business Disadvantages

Looking to learn more about how to start your very own coffee shop? Download our Free eBook here as well as receive our Free newsletter with great tips on how to start your very own coffee shop!

Please note: This blog post is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please consult a legal expert to address your specific needs.